Sign in
Download Opera News App



Collective Action Against Brutality of Cape Town Law Enforcement Injustice


17 January 2022


Following the killing of Dumisani Joxo, an unhoused man, by a City of Cape Town law enforcement officer while a small group of vagrant people were cooking a meal on Sunday 9 January 2022. Various civil society organisations are calling on the public to support collective efforts calling for justice and an end to the brutality of Cape Town law enforcement officers. 

South African Human Rights Commission Meeting on Law Enforcement Brutality and Public Picket

Today at 14:00 - 16:00, the South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC) held a virtual meeting with representatives of communities experiencing homelessness and civil society organisations to discuss the rising levels of brutality directed at poor families and people experiencing homelessness by Cape Town law enforcement officers. Over the last year, the City of Cape Town has adopted a slew of increasingly harsh measures that criminalise homelessness, including the passing of various municipal by laws that make it a crime for persons living on the street to conduct ordinary life sustaining activities, like sleeping, camping, resting, bathing, erecting a shelter or keeping personal belongings in public. These by laws are being challenged in court on the basis that they discriminate against and infringe the fundamental rights of homeless people. 

The SAHRC and NewsReaderSA called on members of the public to gather outside the SAHRC offices at the ABSA building on Riebeeck Street, Cape Town at the same time to picket to show their support for the late Dumisani Joxo, his family, and poor and vagrant people suffering ongoing brutality, threats, intimidation and harassment at the hand of Cape Town law enforcement officers. 

Members of the media and representatives of civil society organisations were invited to attend the online discussion which took place on Microsoft Teams and/or the picket taking place outside.


Funeral Costs for Dumisani Joxo

Despite requests to the City of Cape Town to provide financial assistance to the family of Dumisani Joxo to cover the costs of his funeral, the City has refused to contribute any financial support towards Mr Joxo’s memorial or burial. In fact, hours after Mr Joxo’s memorial service, the City sent correspondence to NewsReaderSA denying that Officer Kati or the City is liable for Mr Joxo’s death and stated that the City will not pay for any costs relating to Dumisani's memorial or burial. The City has done this despite the fact that Mr Joxo and his family are unable to pay for the burial themselves.

Picture above: Dumisani Joxo- Deceased

NewsReaderSA has therefore set up an online fundraising campaign to assist Dumisani Joxo’s family which will cover some of the costs for his funeral. 

While we explore other options, including a potential damages claim against the City, we are calling on the public to contribute towards ensuring that there are funds available to bury Mr Joxo in the Eastern Cape on Saturday so that his body may be laid to rest.

Link to fundraiser:


NewsReaderSA is aware of the City of Cape Town's press statement (12 January) which accuses NU of misleading and false statements. In particular the City noted that:

“The City encourages respect for due process of the official investigation, and notes certain irresponsible and inaccurate statements by one group, NewsReaderSA, regarding this incident. It is necessary to correct these inaccurate statements.”

NewsReaderSA further notes the original press statement issued by the City stated: 

“As of yesterday’s court appearance of a law enforcement officer, no charge of murder has been made as falsely reported in NewsReaderSA release. The matter has instead been postponed to 12 April 2022 as further investigation is required to get to the truth.” 

The City issued this statement despite clear evidence that Officer Kati was charged with murder (see except from the charge sheet below). 

The City’s inaccurate statement has since been removed from the City’s website (as of 15 January 2022). The website makes no indication when this press release was edited or if it has been reissued to the press. NewsReaderSA notes the absurdity of the City accusing NU of false reporting in a statement which itself has irresponsible and inaccurate information. 

The City further claims the open fire was a hazard and defends its current social services towards those who live on the street, which are plainly inadequate. The fire in this particular incident was a contained fire used to cook food and it is inhumane for the City to narrowly define this as a hazard. Making it a crime and issuing fines for people to perform ordinary life sustaining activities such as cooking food is a cruel, inhumane and punitive response to a chronic socioeconomic problem. We call on the City to urgently review its position towards people who live on the streets and acknowledge that its current offerings are vastly inadequate. 

The City’s failure to address a major affordable housing shortage and an inadequate supply of shelter beds means that homelessness, for many, is not a choice. Moreover, the City’s characterisation of people struggling with homelessness as criminals doesn’t address the root causes of homelessness, such as poverty, inadequate affordable housing, a lack of state assistance, mental health issues, substances abuse, and discrimination. The City’s emphasis on law enforcement and punitive measures to deal with homelessness is also expensive and diverts money away from implementing more effective solutions. According to a report by faith-based organisation U-turn, the City spends R744 million a year on people experiencing homelessness - with the City spending a whopping R345 million (or 45%) on enforcement and punitive measures and only R122 million (or 16%) on social development activities. 

We note that the statement claims that law enforcement officers receive six (6) months of training which includes theoretical and supervised practical training. This pales in comparison to the training received by trainee officers of the South African Police Services (SAPS) which constitutes at least 2 years. We note that the City did not confirm whether its officers undergo trauma informed training which leads us to assume that they are not equipped with the necessary skills to engage with streets based communities. We further note the claim that Law Enforcement officers receive the same SASETTA firearm training and call on the City to produce these competency certificates. 

Furthermore, the City maintains its view that people who live on the street harbour criminal elements. NewsReaderSA is concerned with this deeply flawed logic which suggests where a person lives is an indicator of their criminal activity: Homelessness is not a crime but rather a result of a state that has failed to meet people’s needs  

There are no simple solutions to people living on the street, and the City’s insistence on treating people experiencing homelessness as criminals is an ineffective approach targeted only at appeasing ratepayers complaints, without finding sustainable and humane solutions to all persons involved. 




Content created and supplied by: NewsReaderSA (via Opera News )

Cape Town City of Cape Town Dumisani Joxo SAHRC South African Human Rights Commission


Load app to read more comments