Sign in
Download Opera News App

News Politics




Africa politics

Disciplinary inquiry clears Health Director-General Sandile Buthelezi of all charges, lifts suspense

Suspended Health DG Sandile Buthelezi back to paintings on Monday after his suspension turned into lifted. This accompanied a judgment surpassed down ultimate week concluding his disciplinary inquiry. In it, retired decide Cynthia Pretorius declared: ‘There is not any doubt that some of the officers in the NDOH and some politicians have been responsible of the charges, but I cannot find that the worker is guilty. He was unfortunately located in an untenable function and did his utmost to try to rectify the wrongdoing of his predecessor and different events.’

© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved

On Sunday, 28 November, in a letter he received from Minister of International Relations and Cooperation Naledi Pandor, Dr Sandile Buthelezi, the suspended Director-General of the Health Department, learnt that he have been observed not responsible on all five costs towards him and his “precautionary suspension has been lifted with instant effect”.

Buthelezi have been put on suspension in overdue August 2021 after the SIU advocated in its document to President Cyril Ramaphosa that disciplinary movement be taken in opposition to him regarding his alleged position within the Digital Vibes scandal.

[caption id="attachment_1112509" align="aligncenter" width="720"]

buthelezi reinstated virtual vibes pandor© Provided by way of Daily Maverick buthelezi reinstated digital vibes pandor

International Relations and Co-operation Minister Naledi Pandor sent letter lifting his suspension to Health DG Sandile Buthelezi. (Photo: Flickr / GCIS)[/caption]

Because of his seniority, the disciplinary listening to become delegated to the Department of International Relations and Cooperation and a hearing happened on 25 and 26 October, with retired choose Cynthia Pretorius as chairperson.

Buthelezi faced 5 prices:

Gross dereliction of obligation (for failing to stop monthly payments to Digital Vibes after he have become DG in June 2020);

Gross negligence for issuing an “irregular education” to the Chief Finance Officer centralising all the communications contracts, including that with Digital Vibes, in his workplace;

Gross monetary misconduct for failing to stop bills of more than R60-million, in contravention of the PFMA;

Acts of gross misconduct (for approving a finances for Digital Vibes of R85-million for June to December 2020; and

Expenditure emanating from extending the contract to March 2021.

However, as stated by way of Pretorius, “all of the prices are intertwined and interrelated”.

Buthelezi, who testified on his own behalf within the listening to, pleaded not responsible to all the costs.

Buthelezi’s primary defence was that, upon commencing his function because the DG, he had in truth acted well. He pointed out that after first receiving internal worries approximately the Digital Vibes contract from the CFO, Ian van der Merwe, and from the Chief Director: Supply Chain Management, Dikeledi Tshabalala, he had initiated an unbiased forensic investigation by Ngubane Inc into the settlement; later, after the SIU commenced its investigation in March 2021, he said that he cooperated completely with its research.

Buthelezi rejected the concept that he could “micro-manage every and each aspect of every contract at the same time as having so many responsibilities, specifically for the duration of the Covid-19 period”.

However, Buthelezi argued that he couldn't prevent bills or terminate the settlement without sufficient evidence any way and that, earlier than the findings of the Ngubane research, all he had to move on was a caution by using the Auditor-General made in December 2020 that Digital Vibes “might also probable be overcharging the branch”. At that factor, the AG had also endorsed an investigation into Digital Vibes “as an emergency provider for Covid-19”.

Commenting on a controversy which decide Pretorius said “could not be faulted”, she said: “He couldn't suspend the settlement with none evidence there was some thing untoward about the agreement, as it might have constituted a breach of contract, possibly ensuing in litigation.”

Buthelezi stated once he received the initial findings of the forensic audit in March 2021, on the recommendation of the auditors he acted unexpectedly to suspend the agreement. He said that Ngubane Inc’s record, whilst made public in May 2021, did now not discover him implicated within the rip-off: it named as a substitute 4 senior officials against whom disciplinary hearings are ongoing (Maverick Citizen is aware about their names).

After considering the proof and being mildly important of the SIU for now not adequately explaining why Buthelezi had been charged, Pretorius concluded in a way that could have delivered alleviation to Buthelezi, however definitely now not to former Health Minister Zweli Mkhize or others facing inner disciplinary inquiries (the results of which we do no longer but recognise).

In paragraph 71 of her judgment she writes:

“It is apparent from the proof that the Minister and the NDOH had interfered and had signed the submission dated 16 January 2020 as a political workplace bearer and it was no longer signed by way of the executive head of the NDOH. There may be no question that this contract between the NDOH and Digital Vibes constituted an irregularity, however I can not find [Dr Buthelezi] performed any element in contravening the PFMA or wilfully and negligently mismanaged the finances of the country. There is no proof [Buthelezi] become a part of State Capture.

“There is not any doubt that a number of the officials inside the NDOH and some politicians have been guilty of the costs, however I can not locate that the employee is responsible. He became unluckily positioned in an untenable position and did his utmost to try to rectify the wrongdoing of his predecessor and other parties.”

[caption id="attachment_1112508" align="aligncenter" width="720"]

buthelezi reinstated virtual vibes Crisp© Provided by Daily Maverick buthelezi reinstated virtual vibes Crisp

The Health Department’s Deputy Director-General Dr Nicholas Crisp had been acting as DG. (Photo: Leila Dougan)[/caption]

On Monday, Buthelezi’s lawyers, Richard Wands and Rowan Bauer of HJW attorneys, had this to mention: “We consider that the judgment, surpassed down by using retired choose Cynthia Pretorius, is unequivocally clear and demonstrates that Dr Buthelezi changed into no longer worried within the saga, however that he in truth took all reasonable measures to halt any wasteful and unnecessary expenditure within the department and that his movements were past reproach.”

Buthelezi’s return to office coincides with the emergence of the Omicron version of Covid-19. Dr Nicholas Crisp, who has been performing DG, will presumably go back to main the vaccination campaign. DM/MC

Disciplinary inquiry clears Health Director-General Sandile Buthelezi of all charges, lifts suspension (

Content created and supplied by: kingmasterhand (via Opera News )

Cynthia Pretorius Daily Maverick Sandile Buthelezi


Load app to read more comments